| Year | Occupant | Result |
| 1992 | George Bush | LOST to Bill Clinton |
| 1994 | Mitt Romney | LOST to Ted Kennedy |
| 1995 | Bob Dole | LOST to Bill Clinton |
| 1996 | Bill Weld | LOST to John Kerry |
| 1998 | Paul Cellucci | beat Scot Harshbarger |
| 1999 | Pat Buchanan | tbd |
| Overall Record |
| 4-1-1 (W-L-TBD, 80% winning percentage) |